


Climate talks omit people with disabilities
Accessibility has been overlooked by many countries in disaster planning, report says.
When the inevitable hurricanes threaten New Orleans, it’s hard for India Scott to figure out where to go.
In the city where she was born and raised, she has stayed in hotels, relief shelters and, during Hurricane Katrina, in the overcrowded Superdome.
But it is always a gamble choosing where to seek refuge. A lot of places that are safe for most people aren’t safe for her because they aren’t accessible to people like her: people living with disabilities.
Scott has used a wheelchair her entire life; she was born with a disability. Even when the weather is calm in New Orleans, she is reluctant to leave home to visit friends or go out to shop or eat, because there is no guarantee that she’ll be able to maneuver basic tasks such as using the restroom, passing through an entryway or getting into bed.
Scott’s house in the Algiers neighborhood of New Orleans is comfortable, with features that are required by code yet often missing elsewhere, like widened entryways for her wheelchair.
But because she lives near a levee, she leaves that comfort behind whenever a major hurricane or tropical storm is forecast, because flooding that would challenge anyone would surely be fatal for her.
“I try my best to make my home comfortable,” she said, “but if that water ever comes through, I’m in trouble.”
Scott said that when storms come, she can’t rely on the city, state or federal government — only on friends. She said there is inadequate support for people with disabilities before, during and after disasters from emergency management agencies at all levels of government.
“We’re on our own,” she said.
Experts and activists echoed her view, saying people with disabilities are left out of emergency planning and face hurdles that nondisabled people don’t when disasters strike.
As climate-related disasters become more common and more severe, most countries are “neglecting their obligations to respect, protect and fulfill the rights of persons with disabilities in their responses to the climate crisis,” according to a June report from the Disability Inclusive Climate Action Research Program at McGill University and the International Disability Alliance.
The researchers found that only 32 of the 192 countries that are signatories to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change’s 2015 Paris climate accords refer to people with disabilities in their official plans.
Forty-five countries refer to people with disabilities in their climate adaptation policies, and no country mentions disabled people in climate mitigation plans.
Many of the world’s biggest contributors to climate change — the United States, China, Russia, Brazil, Germany, Japan and the United Kingdom — don’t figure people with disabilities into any of these plans, according to the report.
That is despite the fact that 185 countries ratified the United Nations’ Convention on the Rights of Persons With Disabilities, drafted in 2006, which says they will take “all necessary measures to ensure the protection and safety of persons with disabilities in ... humanitarian emergencies and the occurrence of natural disasters.”
The U.S. was one of eight countries that signed the treaty but haven’t ratified it.
People who are disabled are not a small segment of the population.
According to the World Health Organization, there were more than 1 billion people in the world living with a disability in 2011, which was 15% of the global population at the time. (The organization plans to release an update on disability prevalence in December.)
More recently, researchers with the Disability Data Initiative estimated that the percentage of people with disabilities averages 12.6% across 41 countries for which they have data, as of 2021.
One of the researchers, Sophie Mitra, said the WHO figure of 1 billion is likely to have grown since 2011.
“We are still failing people with disabilities, especially multiply marginalized people, before, during and after disasters,” Marcie Roth, chief executive of the World Institute on Disability, told Congress during testimony in July. “We need your help to address urgent, immediate, lifesaving steps [government agencies] can take to serve disaster-impacted people and communities being left out and left behind.”
A clear example of this failure took placeduring the U.N. Climate Change Conference, known as COP26, in November in Glasgow, Scotland.
Israeli Energy Minister Karine Elharrar, who uses a wheelchair, was prevented from entering a conference event by police officers.
A day later, after the incident was publicized, conference organizers and the British government constructed a ramp so Elharrar could attend.
“What happened to the minister of energy happens to us all the time,” said Yolanda Muñoz, a professor at McGill and co-founder of the Disability Inclusive Climate Action Research Program that co-authored the June report. “But, of course, it doesn’t make headlines.”
Another climate activist, Pauline Castres, who worked for the U.N. and has a disability, mourned the return to in-person climate talks that came with COP26.
“I’ve always found those meetings to be quite restrictive in terms of who can attend and who can take part,” she said. “We called [virtual events] one of the few good things that came out of the pandemic.”
But the problems people with disabilities face go beyond access to international conferences and happen on the national, state and local level. When people with disabilities can’t participate in climate planning talks, it’s more likely they won’t be figured into emergency management plans.
Grace Krause, policy officer for Learning Disability Wales, said in a 2019 blog post that it was “alarming” how little information on climate change was presented in an “easy read” format for people with certain cognitive disabilities.
That format uses short sentences, active voice and explanation of any complex words and ideas in a separate sentence. Fonts that make text easier to read for people with dyslexia could also be used to make climate communications more accessible.
In 2019, the U.N. Human Rights Council adopted a resolution calling on governments to take climate action that is inclusive of people with disabilities. But there still isn’t much action from the body’s official climate policy arm, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.
There were two disability-related events at COP26: one on designing cities that are both climate-resilient and accessible and one on mental health and climate action — but they were side events. Disability inclusion in climate action has rarely taken the main stage.
Julia Watts Belser, a Georgetown University professor who uses a wheelchair, said the inclusion of people with disabilities in climate mitigation and adaptation planning “matters deeply” to her.
She leads an initiative at Georgetown exploring the intersection of climate change and disability and teaches a class called “Disability, Ethics, Ecojustice.”
“I think about wanting us as a society to invest in the infrastructure for our communities so that we are better able to adapt and respond,” she said, “so we aren’t leaving people behind, so we aren’t leaving people to die.”